Home News&Events Blog What Is The Difference Between Resistive Touchscreen and Projected Capacitive?

    What Is The Difference Between Resistive Touchscreen and Projected Capacitive?

    When it comes to choosing the right touchscreen technology, Resistive and Projected Capacitive (PCAP) are the two leading options. Each has its own strengths and ideal uses, from the precision of PCAP in consumer devices to the ruggedness of Resistive screens in industrial settings. In this post, we'll compare these technologies to help you decide which suits your needs, whether you're developing consumer electronics or outfitting a factory floor. 

    What is Resistive Touchscreen? 
    A resistive touchscreen is a type of touch-sensitive display that operates by detecting pressure applied to its surface. This screen consists of two flexible layers coated with a conductive material, separated by air gaps or microscopic dots. When pressure is applied, the layers come into contact at the point of touch, enabling the device to determine the location of the input. 

    What is Projected Capacitive (PCAP)? 
    Projected Capacitive (PCAP) technology is a touchscreen method that uses the natural conductivity of the human body to detect touches by measuring changes in an electrical field. Layers of glass or plastic are coated with Indium Tin Oxide (ITO) and arranged in a grid. When touched, the finger disrupts the electrical field, altering the capacitance at that location. The controller then pinpoints the touch location, allowing for precise and responsive multi-touch capabilities. This makes PCAP highly sensitive and clear, suitable for a wide range of applications, from smartphones to industrial panels. 
    Feature  Resistive Touchscreen  Projected Capacitive 
    Working Principle  Uses pressure to create contact between two conductive layers.  Uses multiple layers to detect changes in capacitance. 
    Input Method  Finger, stylus, any object.  Finger, capacitive stylus, thin gloved fingers. 
    Multi-Touch  Limited or none.  Supports complex multi-touch gestures. 
    Durability  Durable, but prone to wear from physical pressure. Highly durable and resistant to scratches. 
    Sensitivity  Requires pressure for input.  Very high sensitivity, no pressure needed. 
    Visibility  Reduced clarity due to additional layers.  Reduced clarity due to additional layers. 
    Cost  Generally lower cost  Higher cost due to complex manufacturing 
    Environmental Resistance  Good resistance to water and dust  Excellent resistance to environment factors 

    What Are Advantages and Disadvantages of Resistive Touchscreen and Projected Capacitive?  
    Resistive Touchscreen 
    • Cost-effective. 
    • Can be used with any type of stylus or even with gloves. 
    • Relatively durable and resistant to water and dust. 
    • Lower screen clarity due to additional layers. 
    • Requires physical pressure, which can be less intuitive. 
    • Offers limited multi-touch capabilities. 
    • Prone to wear and tear from frequent use. 
    Projected Capacitive  
    • Supports multi-touch (pinch, zoom, rotate). 
    • High sensitivity and accuracy. 
    • Works with finger touch and thin gloves. 
    • High clarity and excellent durability. 
    • More complex and expensive to manufacture than resistive and surface capacitive. 
    • Can be affected by extreme electromagnetic interference. 
    • Does not work with standard styluses (requires capacitive stylus). 
    How To Choose The Right Touch Technology? 
    Choosing between PCAP and Resistive touch technology depends on several factors, including the application environment, user interaction requirements, budget constraints, and specific performance needs. Here’s a guide to help determine when to choose each type: 

    When to Choose PCAP Touch: 
    • Multi-Touch Requirements: If your application requires multi-touch capabilities, such as pinch-to-zoom or multi-finger gestures, PCAP is the better choice as it inherently supports these functions. 
    • User Experience: For devices where a high-quality user experience is crucial, such as consumer electronics (smartphones, tablets) or interactive kiosks, PCAP offers superior sensitivity and faster response times. 
    • Visibility and Clarity: If your project demands high screen clarity and brightness, PCAP screens provide better visual quality due to their construction, which does not require multiple layers like resistive screens. 
    • Operating Environment: PCAP is ideal for indoor environments where there is less likelihood of encountering extreme temperatures or heavy wear and tear. It's also a good choice if the device will be used with bare fingers or thin gloves. 
    • Aesthetics: PCAP screens can support sleeker designs as they allow for edge-to-edge glass displays, which are popular in modern device design. 

    When to Choose Resistive Touch: 
    • Cost Concerns: Resistive touchscreens are generally less expensive to produce and are a good choice for budget-sensitive projects. 
    • Harsh Environments: If the device needs to operate in harsh or demanding environments such as industrial settings, outdoor use, or places exposed to water and dust resistive touchscreens are more suitable due to their durability and resistance to external elements. 
    • Versatility in Input: Resistive touchscreens can register touch from any object fingers, gloves, styluses, etc., making them versatile for various applications where the user might not always have bare hands free. 
    • Pressure Sensitivity: For applications that require pressure sensitivity, such as signature capture devices or certain industrial controls, resistive touch technology is effective because it responds to pressure rather than the conductivity of the touch object. 
    • Simple Interactions: If the touchscreen interactions are limited to simple taps and do not require complex gestures, resistive touchscreens can provide a reliable and cost-effective solution. 
    Future Trends in Touchscreen Technology 
    As touchscreen technology advances, Projected Capacitive (PCAP) is expected to see innovations that allow integration with flexible displays, enhanced durability, and improved touch accuracy, potentially expanding into new markets like automotive and healthcare with more cost-effective solutions.  
    Meanwhile, Resistive touchscreens may develop multi-touch capabilities and undergo material innovations to enhance durability and responsiveness. Both technologies aim to improve integration with various devices, particularly in industrial settings, and focus on more eco-friendly practices. These advancements will likely make them more versatile and suitable for a broader range of applications, bridging gaps in performance and environmental impact. 

    How are PCAP and Resistive touch technologies important in the industrial sector? 
    Both PCAP and Resistive touch technologies have transformed the industrial industry by providing durable, efficient, and adaptable control interfaces. These touchscreens help reduce the physical buttons and switches, which streamlines the machinery design and increases the longevity of the devices by limiting mechanical wear and tear. The ability to interact directly with machines through touch interfaces speeds up operations. It can significantly enhance productivity, making these technologies vital components in the ongoing evolution of industrial automation and control systems. 

    Tailoring to Every Need: C&T Panel PC Solutions 
    At C&T, we understand that different industries and applications have unique requirements, so our Panel PCs System are designed to support both Projected Capacitive (PCAP) and Resistive touch technologies. This versatility ensures that we can meet our customers' diverse demands, regardless of their operating environment or specific user interaction needs. Contact us for more information about Panel PCs.

    SIO-200 Series IP66/69K Stainless Panel PC 
    Find Product
    Product Finder